Textile tags and packaging beside a magnifying glass
AI-generated editorial illustration

Define the claim

Does it concern an ingredient, formula, package or supply chain? Broad terms do not establish specific benefits. Natural does not guarantee tolerance; durable may mean lasting construction or environmental performance.

Check scope

For labels identify organisation, standard, version and certified item. EU Ecolabel has textile criteria; one labelled reference does not certify an entire brand. Verify the exact item in official resources.

Compare critically

Separate documented facts from missing information. Missing data is not proof of poor quality, but avoid favourable assumptions. Using a suitable item you own can precede a persuasive new purchase.

A practical example

A package says more responsible without explaining what changed. Look for comparison scope, timeframe and evidence. If absent, record the documentary limit rather than treating the wording as certification.

Check units and percentages

Compare units before percentages. Illustrative example: packaging from 20 g to 10 g is a 50% mass reduction, not 50% less total product impact. Record measured quantity and baseline.

What the EU Ecolabel textile criteria cover

The EU Ecolabel textile criteria address fibres, production processes, hazardous substances and fitness for use. When examining a claim, identify the certified product and the relevant criterion: evidence about the fibre alone does not document the other stages. The official catalogue can be used to look up labelled products.

Identify what the test actually measured

A perception questionnaire records what participants report feeling or observing; an instrumental measurement records a quantity defined by a protocol. These results are not interchangeable. Look for the tested product, participant count, duration and question or criterion assessed. A paper about an ingredient does not automatically establish the same result for a product containing it. The cited best-practice document explains this need for relevance; it does not rank products.

Recover the denominator behind a percentage

Fictional example: if 16 of 20 people answer a question positively, the proportion is 80%. That means neither an 80% improvement in a measurement nor an outcome applying to 80% of the whole population. Another calculation: a quantity rises from 40 to 50 units, an increase of 10 units and 25% relative to 40. Keep respondent share, relative change and absolute difference separate; two prominent numbers cannot be compared without their definitions.

Connect the evidence to the finished product

Regulation (EU) No 655/2013 calls for adequate and verifiable evidence for cosmetic claims. A claim that extends an ingredient’s properties to the finished product needs evidence supporting that extrapolation. In a test summary, check the product studied, benefit assessed and conditions of use.

Check what the environmental claim covers

Directive (EU) 2024/825 provides for national measures to apply from 27 September 2026. The rules address generic claims without recognised excellent environmental performance. Check whether the evidence covers the whole product or one part. For example, evidence about recycled plastic in the bottle should be presented as a claim about the bottle.

Distinguish reductions from offsets

The directive addresses claims that a product has a neutral, reduced or positive greenhouse gas impact when these claims are based on offsetting. Look for what was measured in the product life cycle, the scope and the time period. For a sustainability label, identify the public authority or certification scheme behind it.

Questions for examining a claim
What to examinePractical checkUseful decision
ScopeWhole product, component or packaging?Do not extend evidence to another object
EvidenceDocument, method and date available?Separate assertion from verification
ComparisonSame function and basis?Avoid ranking from a single word

Put it into practice

An editorial planning method to adapt to your situation.

Put it into practice
SituationObserve or askNext step
Claim about a whole rangeExact product, evidence and claimed scopeCheck that evidence applies to your reference
Comparing two labelsCriteria, holder and accessible certificateCompare scopes rather than counting logos

Your checklist

Frequently asked questions

Is a logo enough?

No. Meaning depends on standard, scope and verifiable attribution.

Is old evidence always enough?

No. Check validity and match to the current product.

Sources & references

Beauty directory

Brands, online shops and beauty magazines: explore their official websites and areas of focus.